Pep Guardiola’s Terrible 2024/25 Season Start- Is This the End of an Era?

Pep Guardiola’s managerial career at Manchester City has been legendary. From his treble-winning season in 2023 to his dominance of the Premier League, Guardiola has established City as one of the best coaches in world football.

However, as the start of the 2024/25 season unfolded, Catalonian gaffer Pep Guardiola has faced a terrible start, with the reigning champions facing unexpected dips in form domestically and in Europe.

With recent losses in the Premier League and UEFA Champions League, questions are beginning to emerge: What’s behind this downturn, and what does it mean for the team, its fans, and Guardiola’s legacy?

The Decline in Form: What’s Behind It?

Tactical Adjustments and Shifting Dynamics:

Guardiola is known for his tactical innovation, but his methods face increasing resistance this season. One of the most glaring issues has been a lack of fluidity in City’s attacking play. While the squad still boasts world-class talent like Erling Haaland and Kevin De Bruyne, the team has struggled to generate the same cohesive attacking patterns that characterized their best performances in previous seasons.

Guardiola’s tactical tweaks—such as experimenting with inverted full-backs and relying on possession-heavy play—have not been as effective. With opposing teams increasingly setting up to frustrate City, Guardiola’s system has been less adaptable than usual, making it easier for opponents to stifle the creativity that once made City unstoppable.

Injuries and Squad Depth

Another factor contributing to Manchester City’s poor form has been injuries to key players. Kevin De Bruyne, one of the team’s most crucial creative outlets, has been sidelined for significant periods. His absence has placed tremendous pressure on other players like Phil Foden and Jack Grealish to fill the void, but neither has consistently stepped up in the way City fans would hope. In midfield, Rodri’s absence has been equally damaging, exposing a lack of depth in critical areas of the pitch.

While City’s squad is undoubtedly one of the deepest in Europe, the team’s struggles to adapt without their key players. This has highlighted an issue Guardiola has yet to resolve fully: the balance between rotation and continuity. With so many high-stakes matches, Guardiola’s decision to rotate players extensively may have backfired, leading to a lack of rhythm at a crucial point in the season.

Mental and Emotional Fatigue

Having seen a season where Manchester City captured the Champions League, Premier League, and FA Cup, the emotional and mental toll on the squad cannot be overlooked. Guardiola’s side has delivered some of the most exhilarating football in history over the past few years. However, whether the squad has the same hunger and intensity is still being determined.

City has looked physically and mentally fatigued in many recent losses, struggling to break down opposition defenses and respond to setbacks.

This lack of motivation and sharpness could result from the immense pressure on the team to maintain such a high standard.

Guardiola’s meticulous approach to detail might not be enough to keep the players as sharp and hungry as they were when they were fighting for their first Premier League title under his stewardship.

Opposition Adaptations

Lastly, it’s worth considering how other teams have adapted to Guardiola’s style. City has been so dominant that many teams have now developed strategies to nullify Guardiola’s tactics. Teams are increasingly pressing high and forcing City into making mistakes at the back while limiting space for players like Haaland and De Bruyne to operate in the final third. Guardiola’s famous possession-based football is no longer the novelty it once was; now, it is a blueprint many managers have learned to counter.

Don’t miss: The Jose Mourinho and Pep Guardiola Verbal Fight Rivalry

Impact on Manchester City and Its Fans

On the Team:

For Manchester City, this poor run of form could have long-lasting consequences on the morale of the squad. The pressure is mounting while the club is still filled with elite players. Defeats in both the Premier League and Champions League raise doubts about the team’s ability to bounce back and claim more silverware this season. Are the players beginning to lose faith in Guardiola’s methods? Are cracks forming in the unity that has defined City’s success under the Spaniard?

Internally, Guardiola will need to act quickly to address these concerns. A lack of cohesion and mounting frustration from key players could lead to further complications. For a manager known for his close relationship with his players, this could be a critical turning point in his tenure at City.

On the Fans:

Manchester City fans have grown accustomed to winning titles and dominating the Premier League under Guardiola, but this recent slump has begun to test their patience. Despite the team’s historical success, the pressure is mounting. Losing to rivals and dropping points against lower-tier teams has led to some unrest among the fanbase, and many are starting to question whether the team’s remarkable achievements over the last few years have made them complacent.

The Champions League, which had been the elusive prize for City for so long, remains a primary goal. Fans are worried that a second consecutive disappointing campaign in Europe might cost them the chance to add another major trophy to their collection, especially after the high expectations set by last season’s historic treble.

Don’t miss: Pep Guardiola Extends Manchester City Contract by Two-Years

Guardiola’s Legacy: Is This the End of an Era at City?

For all the trophies Guardiola has won and the footballing revolution he’s led at Manchester City, this current slump raises an important question: Is this the end of Pep Guardiola’s era at Manchester City?

Guardiola’s philosophy has undoubtedly transformed City into a global powerhouse, and his influence on football is beyond dispute. But could it tarnish his standing at the club if this poor run continues?

Football fans are notoriously short-sighted, and while Guardiola’s legacy is secure for now, a prolonged period of underachievement could change the narrative. In the high-pressure world of modern football, even the most successful managers can find their tenure under scrutiny. If Guardiola cannot turn things around, the once-untouchable status of the manager and the team could be challenged.

In an interview with Sky Sports, Guardiola said:

“[The owners] know when the situation is bad and we start to lose games, then it is not sustainable. Then I would not be here next month or in the next two months.

“The results dictate that – and this is the reality. We cannot eternally lose games. Maybe because what we have done in the past [people will think I wouldn’t be sacked] but we are judged daily as managers.

“In one bad season, you can be out. The club knows that I will not do it [resign]. The club would have to do it. I want to be close to the players.

I want to be beside them. We’ve lost a lot of games – more than we have in two seasons”.

While it’s too early to declare Guardiola’s time at Manchester City over, the mounting pressure to turn things around is undeniable. If City fails to make a significant recovery, questions will inevitably arise—about Guardiola’s tactics, his leadership, and whether this cycle of dominance has reached its natural conclusion.

Can Guardiola Turn It Around?

At this point in the season, it’s clear that Pep Guardiola faces one of the biggest challenges of his career. The dip in form may be temporary, or it could signal deeper issues within the team. However, if anyone can fix these problems, it’s Guardiola. He’s repeatedly proven that he can adapt to adversity and reinvent his approach when necessary.

Join the Conversation

What are your thoughts on Guardiola’s recent struggles? Do you think Manchester City can recover, or is this the beginning of the end for Guardiola’s dominance in English football? Share your thoughts below!

How does this sound? It’s designed to be critical and analytical, with plenty of room for fans to think about the bigger picture. Let me know if you’d like any adjustments or additions!

Don’t miss: Jack Grealish’s New Chance to Redemption under Pep Guardiola

1. What are the main reasons behind Manchester City’s poor start to the 2024/25 season under Pep Guardiola?

Several factors contributed to Manchester City’s struggles in the early 2024/25 season. These include injuries to key players, particularly in the defensive and midfield areas, and a dip in form from some of their star performers. Additionally, Guardiola’s tactical adjustments in response to changing opposition strategies have yet to click, leading to inconsistent performances. A challenging fixture list and the departures of some experienced squad members may also be playing a role.

2. Is Pep Guardiola’s tactical approach no longer working for Manchester City?

While Guardiola’s tactics have been highly successful for years, some analysts argue that the team’s reliance on his intricate possession-based style is becoming more predictable, especially against teams that press high or adopt a more direct approach. There have been signs that opposing managers are countering Guardiola’s methods more effectively. However, it’s important to note that this is still a temporary phase, and Guardiola has often been able to adapt and evolve his tactics over time.

3. Has Manchester City’s squad become weaker under Pep Guardiola’s leadership?

While Manchester City’s squad remains one of the strongest in Europe, the 2024/25 season has exposed some depth issues, particularly in areas like defense and midfield. The departures of important players and the inability to adequately replace them have led to a noticeable gap in quality. Additionally, some of their older players may not be performing at their peak, while younger recruits still need time to adapt. The evolving nature of top-tier football means Guardiola must constantly refresh his squad to stay competitive, which could be one of his challenges this season.

4. Could this end an era for Pep Guardiola at Manchester City?

While it’s too early to say definitively, the 2024/25 season marks a pivotal moment in Guardiola’s reign. His legacy at Manchester City is secure, with multiple league titles, FA Cups, and a Champions League victory. Still, the struggles this season raise questions about whether he can maintain the same level of success moving forward. If the current issues persist—especially if City fails to compete for top honors—it could signal the end of an era, particularly with new challenges emerging in English football and the broader European landscape.

5. What impact would a poor 2024/25 season have on Pep Guardiola’s future at Manchester City?

A poor season could force Manchester City’s ownership to re-evaluate their long-term plans. Guardiola has enjoyed remarkable success since joining the club in 2016, but a significant decline in performance could lead to pressure from both fans and the board. However, given Guardiola’s standing at the club and his track record of delivering success, it’s more likely that the club will give him time to resolve the issues. That said, the pressure will be on to return to form and maintain the elite standards that Manchester City have become accustomed to under his leadership.